Wednesday 23rd November 1994 – age 13
Dear Diary,
I went to see the school show ‘Oliver’ tonight. ‘Oliver’ is so gorgeous I couldn’t keep my eyes off him. He has hair like this (small drawing of a head and his hairstyle) He is the cutest, most adorable, sweetest, most gorgeous boy I’ve ever set eyes on!
Thursday 24th November 1994
Dear Diary,
I saw him today, he is lovely but hasn’t noticed me and probably never will!
(Various other not very interesting entries…then)
Tuesday 14th February 1995
Dear Diary,
I gave him a box of sweets today and he gave me a card after school – quote
“Roses are Red
Violets are Blue
No-one can make me happy
except for you!”
oh boy!
Thursday 16th February 1995
Dear Diary,
Rachel & Fraser say it’s his Birthday today or tomorrow, I must get him a present.
Friday 17th February 1995
Dear Diary,
I give him a card and a toy dog for his birthday, he says he’ll call it after me! I hope he doesn't mean I'm a dog.
Tuesday 21st February 1995
Dear Diary,
He wrote me a letter today telling me that Rachel has been sending him letters telling him how much she loves him and that she wants to go out with him. But he says he would hate to go out with her which makes me feel a lot better although it’s not as if he would want to go out with me! But at least he doesn’t like her. I just wish she knew that. He also wrote – PS. My birthday isn’t till the 27th! Damn Rachel that little liar.
Monday 27th February 1995
Dear Diary,
It’s his actual birthday today so I gave him a chocolate dopey from the 7 dwarfs.
Wednesday 1st March 1995
Dear Diary
I don’t think he liked the chocolate dopey as I haven’t heard from him since…
Thursday 2nd March 1995
Dear Diary,
Emma says she asked him if he liked me and he said ‘Yes’ then she asked him if he fancied me and he said ‘Yes’!! Yaaas!!
This went on for years…
My parents and brother knew all about this boy, they couldn’t not know! I’d get up in the morning and watch the VHS of the school show. He was perfection and I couldn’t get enough of him. Of course ‘Oliver’ has become my all-time favourite musical as I know every single word of it and the ‘I’d do anything’ song is one of those songs that often gets stuck in my head for weeks on end.
On bonfire night in 1997, we were both 16 and at our local bonfire, which by the way they no longer hold there for health and safety reasons – another example of bureaucracy gone mad. I was there with my friends and he was there with his. After the crowds went home a few of us stayed behind and sat and enjoyed the warmth that was left. At one point he kissed me. He actually kissed me. He was kissing ME! After that we were too shy to talk about it, we were too shy to do anything about it. I remember wondering why I didn’t just write him another letter but those days were long gone, we were too cool for that now and nothing ever came of it. The following summer he left school and I met my future husband.
I went to the same University as him and when I saw him I was so embarrassed about all the letters I’d take a quick turn to avoid him and duck out of the way, I didn’t know what to say to him. We were only at the same Uni for 1 yr so that wasn’t too awkward. One time, when still students, in town with friends I went into a bar to find him working there, I pushed back through the crowd and sent a friend up to buy the drinks instead, the memories of all the letters, poems and gifts were making me cringe too much to be able to face him EVER again.
Then about 4 years ago I got an email saying he’d added me on Bebo! (Social networking site popular before Facebook for those of you who are wondering) Ahhhhhh! I nearly fell off of my seat! I got over excited and sent him a msg saying something along the lines of ‘OMG You’re like a famous person to me’ That night I was out for dinner with the girls and I told them he added me on Bebo. Of course they knew all about him and asked what I'd sent back, the looks on their faces when I told them showed me they were disgusted! Apparently this is not the right etiquette. But we used to just write whatever we wanted when we were 13, 14 & 15. I was told this was no longer acceptable in your mid-twenties. Ooops!
Thankfully he laughed in his response and we reminisced about old times, it seems he’d kept all our letters and jokingly started to quote from them online! One of my friends offered him cash to buy them all from him but fortunately he didn’t sell them to her as that would have been mortifying! We talked a bit for a few weeks, he wrote me an email asking me out for a drink, I wrote back and say yes, I heard nothing more.
About 6 years ago I threw a Halloween party in town, he and his friends decided to come and arrived dressed as the YMC. He came as the Indian - I was a witch. It was strange to see him again after about 9years, kind of weird, kind of wonderful. He was lovely, funny and handsome still. Our emails carried on here and there for months.
Then a few years ago he moved abroad to work, we talked about everything on our emails by this stage but still we’d not actually met up one-to-one. Over the first two years he was abroad he wrote to me a lot, some weeks he wrote 2,500 word emails, I’d reply and the following day I get another 2,500 word email straight back. I spoke to one of my friends about it and he advised that either, the guy is just really chatty, or he’s really into me.
Then he met a girl in this far off country so I had to assume it’s that he’s just really chatty and I left it at. The emails continued every week or so and then two summers ago I was clearing out the attic at a house I rent out and I found my old diary and the video of the school show!! This is where the quotes above come from, it’s cringe-worthy but very funny, and I emailed him some examples for his entertainment. So we joked about that for a while.
Then about 2 years ago I received an email to say he’s been dreaming about me, and then he proceeded to tell me what happened in the dream which was really quite sensual, I laugh it off but found it to be a strange thing to say to someone who is not your girlfriend.
He wrote again a few weeks later, full of chat and news, one piece of news was that he’d moved in with his girlfriend, so I pondered this for a few days and I held off replying. I concluded that I ought to leave this email relationship as an ‘if only’. As ‘the one that got away’. As the ‘first love’ that I had in my teens and keep this romantic image as it is. I should let him go and build his life with this girl without this strong friendship with me distracting him in any way. Then one night whilst I was still pondering all of this and before I had a chance to respond to his last email, he emailed again;
“I'd do anything, for you dear anything, cos you mean everything to me....
You bloody do too. Did I ever tell you that my sister loves you?
And so do I. I love you.
I wish I’d been smarter and realised a good thing when I had it.
x x x x”
I couldn’t believe that he’d started the email with the line from this song. I couldn’t believe he’d written what he’d written. What did he expect me to think about this? What was I meant to do about this? What is it with men? What am I supposed to say?
After much consideration I responded the next day saying “Sorry I know I haven't yet replied to your last email but I'm waiting the obligatory 3 weeks. With regard to the msg you sent last night - I'm not sure whether to assume you were drunk or not?” I was playing it cool, giving him the chance to say ooops that wasn’t for me (though it could surely only be for me with its content?!)
He responded…
“Ok, my email...yes I was a little drunk when I sent that. I was watching TV and there was a show on about Benidorm or someplace like that and it made me think back to a holiday I had when I was about 17.
I remember being in Aya Napa or somewhere ghastly like that and I recall thinking about you a fair bit. I was determined that when I got back to the UK I was going to ask you out. I can't remember why I didn't now. I think it was because I'd just left school and I didn't have your phone number or address. Anyway, I didn't ask you out and the rest is history.
So that led to me thinking about you so I sent you that drunken note. As I state, I should be apologetic and ashamed of it, but I'm not at all.
I'll now go through the mail and attempt to regain some dignity:
I would do anything for my friends and over the years I believe we have become very good email friends. Therefore I would do anything for you.
Did I ever tell you that my sister loves you? I think I did didn't I? Or did I?
Yes, in some way shape or form, I love you too.
And yes, I should have been smarter and been nicer to you when you stalked me. Who knows what may have happened? We'd have split up after three weeks and never spoken again, that's what. But seriously, who knows? It obviously wasn't meant to be and thankfully we do speak and have become friends. In fact, you're the only person from school that I speak to on a regular basis! How about that eh?
Right, I've explained myself and await your mail missy!“
I didn’t respond. I couldn’t bring myself to write a single word. I didn’t keep in touch. I moved to London and I forgot all about him as best as I could. I knew I had thought too much of it all and his cryptic message had sent my heart and stomach into uncontrollable cartwheels. So when he explained it all away with just a wave of his hand I was absolutely floored.
In the couple of years since I moved I did contact him about 15months ago to ask if he’s help my best friend who was looking to move to his city. He and his girlfriend met up with her and she said it was helpful. I know she expected me to ask all about what the girlfriend was like but I didn’t. I’ve moved on. I’m not interested. He messaged me at Hogmanay last year (New Year to all you non-Scots) and that obviously made my night! We promised to get in touch in the New Year. We didn’t.
Then a little while ago I got a message from him asking if it was still my number. I replied to say it was still my number but was I who he was looking for? He replied that I was definitely who he was looking for but that if I didn’t know maybe he would keep it a secret. (At this point, because he used the word ‘definitely’ I was giddy with excitement like a stupid 12yr old girl who has not yet learned that boys are rubbish and we should throw stones at them) Anyway after various messages he says he was in London a few months ago and meant to get in touch but didn’t. When I asked why he said it was because I’d not been in touch. So confusion has once again set in. I’m not sure why he keeps getting back in touch and why he feels its ok to write that he loves me then swiftly clarifies that he doesn’t mean ‘LOVE love’. I am back on the rollercoaster I first unknowingly stepped onto when I was 12. You’d have thought after 18 years I’d have moved on. But I really haven’t.
So now we’re another 6 months down the line and we haven’t been in touch. I know I shouldn’t lose a friend but we were never really friends in real life. We were pen pals at school (albeit one I’ve been a little bit in love with since I was 12) we became online friends thanks to Bebo and FaceBook and we shared our lives with each other through masses of huge emails but we’ve spent only a handful of times in each other’s company so why is it so hard not to have him in my life? It really is.
I honestly had tried not to think about him for a long time, I got the VHS of the school show copied to DVD a few months ago purely to protect it so I had a digital copy but haven’t been able to bring myself to watch it as I’m sure I’ll cry my heart out.
For all my talk about the boy that recently came to tell me how he felt and I told him I wasn't interested I guess in the same way that he did I have now realised I too need to unburden myself of the feeling that I missed out on something.
I know he's just my 'one that got away' and that I should only think of him as the first boy to make my tummy do summersaults. I know I should remember him like everyone else remembers a boy they had a crush on at school. I know I should forget him, I know I should forget that for over 18 years of my life, through my marriage and all the other relationships I’ve had “I’d have done anything…” and I mean absolutely anything… to have been with this man. But I’ve realised now that sometimes ‘anything’ just isn’t enough.
He’s happy now and so am I. Maybe we should stay friends. Maybe he’ll read this and we won’t.



